It began as a simple request.
"Boys? Could you please clean up your fort in the basement like you promised Daddy you would?"
At first they obeyed. Well, P balked and cried but G told him they should hurry and do it so they could get back to playing. (!!) Such logic from my firstborn son! I was pleasantly surprised at the speed and cooperation they exhibited in getting the job done.
As they passed back through the kitchen on their way upstairs, I said, "Now, please pick up the rest of the legos and crayons on your floor, okay?"
At first they seemed all right with that request, too.
After I finished in the kitchen, I went to stoke the fire. I noticed P had wandered back downstairs. "Are you done, buddy?" I asked. He shook his head, and zipped back upstairs.
The next thing I knew, G was calling to me. "Mom! Phe is yeavin'! He is wunnin' away!" Sure enough, there was P on the steps with a bag of play food -- two pretend pizzas and a foam orange. His feet were bare. He said he was leaving because I am always so mean.
I told him I hoped he wouldn't go, and asked that he at least wait until tomorrow, since it's cold out. I opened the front door for him, and he stuck out his chubby hand. He decided he'd wait until tomorrow morning. I congratulated myself on having handled the situation so splendidly.
Then, I broke the news that there would be no stories. It was already late, and even without stories they wouldn't be in bed until after 8. That was the last straw for P. He grabbed his bag of play food and announced he was leaving, and that from now on he could be reached at his friend Timmy's house, around the corner. The other children commenced yelling and wailing. The chaos got the better of me, and I called his bluff.
"Fine. If you're leaving tonight, it's time to go because I have other kids to put to bed," I said. "Otherwise, you need to get upstairs and put on your jammies."
"I'm yeavin' tonight," he said.
"All right. We'll miss you," I said, as I swung open the door.
As we stood on the threshhold, 30 degree air flooding into the house, I knew I'd pushed him too far. I knew he wouldn't leave, or if he did he wouldn't go any further in his bare feet than the frigid sandstone sidewalk. I knew that even if he bolted for it, I would catch him. I knew Timmy's parents would let him in and make him feel better. But I also knew I shouldn't have painted him into a corner.
"Won't you please wait until tomorrow, at least?" I asked.
Grateful for an out, he agreed he would, and we headed upstairs where I found G huddled against the wall, between the bed and the nightstand, sobbing. He was inconsolable. He truly believed P was going to leave. It sounds cute, I know, but his grief was so overwhelming. I started to feel like I might throw up.
While I held G and the girls and I tried to console him, P sat on his bed quietly wiping tears from his eyes. I whispered in G's ear, told him I'd never really let P leave, and even if he left I'd go get him, but G didn't respond except to continue howling. After a while he sobbed to his brother, "What will you eat? Where will you live?"
And P replied that he now planned to go live with his aunt, and she would take care of him. He wanted to live with her because she is never mean. He said he'd leave tomorrow morning and run to her house. (She lives about four hours away.)
Again seeing an opportunity to bring this to a close, I suggested that he wait until Saturday and catch a ride with us. He was agreeable. G sobbed harder. "And den we will YEAVE him dere?"
"No, no," I whispered in his ear. "No, I would never leave him."
I started to sense that the twin factor rendered useless all of the preschool runaway strategies employed by my parents.
After a while P backed down, saying he wouldn't really stay at his aunt's. I showered him with kisses and love, borne of my relief that this ordeal was at an end. I told G the good news, and patted the bed for him to come over and be tucked in.
"No, I'm sleepin' on the floor because my heart is broken," he said.
What? But but but...
"Half of my heart is healed, but the other half is still broken so I don't want to sleep in bed with P," he explained.
P began to cry again, and once again threatened to leave. His exact words were, "If you do one more thing that is bad to me, I'm headin' out." I explained that he was certain to be angry at me again because we are family and that happens, but that families always love each other and he couldn't just leave...
My Todd Parr explanation only served to enrage him. G started crying again. "Will you at least stay until I can make us Best Buddies Forever goodie bags?" he begged. Oh, my heart, it is shattering into a thousand pieces.
I convinced G to come lay in bed with me and P. I held them both, their heads leaned against each other like when they used to doze off nursing. P put his arm around G, and G rested his head on P's chest and shoulder. "Are you still gonna yeave?" he asked.
"I don't know," P answered.